Top 5 Indoor Tanning Lotions for Sensitive Skin in 2021

Finding the best indoor tanning lotion for sensitive skin can be a bit of a hustle!

I mean, sensitive skin and the tanning process don’t really go hand in hand, do they?

Except they do.

Prepare to get your tan on as we take a look at the best of the best sunless tanning lotion for sensitive skin beauties.

Let’s start with a quick look at our top picks, then keep reading for all the glorious details.

READ MORE: 5 Best Tanning Bed Lotion for Beginners

Best Indoor Tanning Lotion for Sensitive Skin Top Picks at a Glance

If you see the value in these products and choose to purchase via my referral links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

WINNER!
Preview
Hempz Dark Tan Maximizer, Hypoallergenic, 9 Ounce
Top Benefit
Made with natural ingredients to accelerate the tanning process.
Check Latest Price
Super Hydrating Tanner
Preview
Devoted Creations #TANLIFE Hydrating Tanning Butter - 12.25 oz.
Top Benefit
Free of tinglers
Check Latest Price
Best Dark Tanning Accelerator
Preview
Maui Babe Browning Lotion 8 Ounces
Top Benefit
Infused with Kona caffeine extracts, aloe, and Kukui Nut Oil
Check Latest Price
Best Facial Tanner
Preview
Level 2 Medium Self Tanner Organic & Natural, Body & Face, Bahama Tan Self Tanning Lotion, No Orange Streak-Free Sunless Tanner, 7.5 oz with Pump
Top Benefit
Non-comedogenic and won’t clog pores
Check Latest Price

5 Best Tanning Lotions for Sensitive Skin W/ Review

There ain’t nothing better than walking out of my front door with a golden glow! Oh, to sit outside and soak up the sun! But who has the time?

I know some ladies have that melanin production thing going on naturally, and I’m happy for them (albeit a little jealous, just a tiny bit!) But thanks to a sunless tanner, we can all get that radiant glow at home!

If you’ve got any other skin types, you may want to check out the five best tanning bed lotions to try.

But if you’ve got sensitive skin like me, check this comprehensive review out to get the best bronzing tanning lotion that promises a sunkissed glow.

1. Hempz Dark Tan Maximizer, Hypoallergenic (Overall Winner!)

Hempz Dark Tan Maximizer, Hypoallergenic, 9 Ounce

The Hempz brand has been around for more than twenty years and is famous for the Hemp Seed Oil, one of the active ingredients in this fantastic product!

Features

Natural Hemp Seed oil contains anti-inflammatory compounds such as antioxidants, fatty acids, and CBD that helps target skin concerns such as pain and itchiness.

contains calming extracts of Oatmeal to soothe and comfort pale skin.

The product is hypoallergenic and completely free of harmful chemicals such as parabens, glutens, nuts, and THC, an ideal choice for those looking to boost their melanin activity.

Mango Seed Butter blend helps keep the skin hydrated and provides soft skin. And the product is 100% vegan.

The product itself is colorless and will not stain your clothes or your hands during application. While some consumers use it just as it is, others have loved the results when combined with an indoor tanning bed.

BenefitsDrawbacks
Contains natural hemp seed oil that has anti-inflammatory properties on the skin.Can cause breakouts in some skin types.
Made with natural ingredients to accelerate the tanning process. Does not give a very dark tan.
Hypoallergenic, i.e., no allergic reaction on sensitive skin.
Free of parabens, glutens, nuts and THC.
Will not stain hands or clothes upon application.

How it Compares to Other Products

This perfect tanning lotion formula is non-greasy and lightweight; your skin will instantly bring forth tanning effects. The best part is the effects of applying this product will show itself in the very first use.

Expert Tips

Hempz Dark Tan Maximizer can be used both on your body and face, but mix in an SPF while applying it to delicate skin.

Hempz Dark Tan Maximizer, Hypoallergenic, 9 Ounce
  • 1.Natural calming extracts including Oatmeal to comfort and soothe.
  • 2.Blended with rich Mango Seed Butter to help hydrate and smooth gentle skin.
  • 3.Non-greasy, lighweight formula absorbs quickly into the skin.
  • 4.Paraben Free, Gluten Free, Nut Free, 100% Vegan, THC-Free.

2. Devoted Creations #TANLIFE Hydrating Tanning Butter (Super Hydrating Tanner)

Devoted Creations #TANLIFE Hydrating Tanning Butter - 12.25 oz.

If you’re looking for a golden tanning lotion (and to be honest, who isn’t?), this one by Devoted Creations might just be what you’re looking for.  

We all want the #tanlife tanning process that promises a golden glow without hurting our sensitive skin.

Features

The tanner itself is white, meaning it will not stain your hands or clothes after application, and we all know what a headache that can be. 

It provides anti-aging benefits to consumers with Body Fit, RevitaFit, and Advanced Matrixyl Synthe 6.

The AcquaCell in the formula helps battle fine lines and wrinkles.

BenefitsDrawbacks
Infused with hydrating shea butter to keep skin soft and hydrated.Can cause clogging of pores.
Loaded with anti-aging ingredients that help battle wrinkles and fine lines.May cause rashes in some people.
Does not stain hands or clothes upon application.
Is free of tinglers and does not mess with skin sensitivity.

How it Compares to Other Products

The Devoted Creations #TANLIFE Hydrating Tanning Butter is infused with shea butter that helps keep skin healthy and hydrated. AND give it a golden color that is the source of all envies!

Devoted Creations #TANLIFE Hydrating Tanning Butter - 12.25 oz.
  • 1.Super soft tanning butter build and maintain skin's natural glow.
  • 2.Sensitive Skin Shea Butter Formula.
  • 3.Provides anti-aging and skin firming benefits with RevitaFit, Body Fit and Advanced Matrixyl Synthe 6.
  • 4.AcquaCell for fine line and wrinkle reducing benefits.
  • 5.Tattoo & Color Fade Protectors

3. Maui Babe Browning Lotion (Best Dark Tanning Accelerator)

Maui Babe Browning Lotion 8 Ounces

Features

This accelerator tanning lotion has been power-packed with organic ingredients such as Kona coffee extract, aloe, and Kukui Nut Oil.

Other components include light mineral oil and antioxidant vitamins E, C, and A.

Reviewers love the sweet scent their skin gets after using the tanning lotion.

It leaves skin feeling oily and hydrated and does not cause skin irritation.

However, it does cause a little bit of staining on hands and light-colored clothes. 

BenefitsDrawbacks
Secret Hawaiian formula that adds instant color to your skin.Can cause staining on hands and light-colored clothes.
Infused with Kona caffeine extracts, aloe, and Kukui Nut Oil.May feel too greasy on oily skin.
Provides a beautiful glow to the skin.

How it Compares to Other Products

The Maui Babe Tanning Salon Formula is infused with a secret Hawaiian formula, so secret that the makers don’t even talk about it.

Sale
Maui Babe Browning Lotion 8 Ounces
  • SIZE: Easy-open 8 ounce bottle
  • DESCRIPTION: All natural browning lotion made from a secret Hawaiian formula
  • USES: Yields a beautiful natural tan by accelerating the sun triggered tanning process
  • DETAILS: Designed for all skin types and tones, including sensitive and fair skin
  • ORIGIN: Imported from Maui, Hawaii

4. Botanic Tree Self Tanner- Organic Sunless Tanless (Best Budget Buy) 

Botanic Tree Self Tanner

Sometimes self-tanners can go all kinds of wrong, and you come out looking orange instead of a brown goddess. Thankfully, not with this one!

Features

This streak-free bronzer will get your skin to look sunkissed, not like an Oompa Loompa. (And I’ve been there. Trauma!)

This organic tanner is fast-absorbing and will not stain clothes or leave dark spots.

BenefitsDrawbacks
All-natural formula without parabens or toxic chemicals. Tan can wear off unevenly.
Will not stain clothes. Can stain hands if not washed immediately.
Infused with Shea butter and fruit extracts. 

How it Compares to Other Products

Infused with shea butter and fruit extracts, you get gorgeous color and hydrated skin. 

Expert Tip

You could put on your clothes instantly after application, but we recommend you wait a while anyway to make sure.

Sale
Botanic Tree Self Tanner-Organic Sunless Tanner for Natural-Looking Fake Tan-Herbal Self Tanning Lotion for Flawless Bronzer Skin-Instant Face and Body Tanner for Fair and Dark Skin.
  • The Safest Way to Get Amazing Color: Our plant-based, natural and organic self tanner, gives you an amazing bronzed complexion without exposure to UV Rays or harmful chemicals. When it comes to beauty products, our tanning lotion is a standout.
  • Look Sun-Kissed, Never Orange: Our streak-free bronzer lotion will leave your skin perfectly tanned without turning it orange. For an easy and even application and beautiful bronzed tone, our sunless tanning lotion is the perfect solution. Simply apply a thin layer to clean, exfoliated skin, and stay moisturized for best results.
  • Keep Your Clothes Clean: Our tan lotion is fast-absorbing — so you get a beautiful tan without staining your clothes or leaving dark spots on towels and sheets. In fact, you can put your clothes on immediately after application of our sunless tanner!
  • Self Tan While You Moisturize: Our self tanner lotion is rich in Shea Butter and 10 organic fruit extracts that leave your skin hydrated, refreshed and rejuvenated. Get two benefits in one from our self tanning lotion — gorgeous color and plump, hydrated skin.
  • All-Natural and Made in the USA: Unlike tanning mousse or spray self tanner, our indoor tanning lotion is made, cruelty-free in the USA, with zero parabens or toxic chemicals. Use it for self tanning your body or as a face tanner — either way you’ll get realistic-looking color with skin-saving nutrients.

5. Bahama Tan Level 2 Self Tanner (Best Facial Tanner) 

Level 2 Medium Self Tanner Organic & Natural, Body & Face

Features

This product is formulated with sensitive skin-friendly ingredients such as coconut oil and argan oil.

Made without parabens, alcohols, and sulfates, all you get is lovely tanned skin without adverse reactions.

The Bahama Tan is non-comedogenic and can be applied to the face without worrying about clogged pores. 

BenefitsDrawbacks
Infused with ingredients such as coconut oil and argan oil. Can stain light-colored clothes.
Non-comedogenic and won’t clog pores. Smell can feel overpowering to some users.
Formulated without parabens, alcohol, or sulfates. 

How it Compares to Other Products

The lotion helps bring forth a gorgeous tan in about four to seven days without any streaks or blotchiness, thanks to its skin-friendly ingredients.

Level 2 Medium Self Tanner Organic & Natural, Body & Face, Bahama Tan Self Tanning Lotion, No Orange Streak-Free Sunless Tanner, 7.5 oz with Pump
  • HAPPINESS GUARANTEE: We're so confident that you will love Bahama Tan that we have a no-questions asked money back guarantee!
  • YOUR PERFECT TAN COLOR: Develop your own personal tan color as dark as you want to go with No streaking, No orange, No blotchiness and No toxic chemicals. Simply apply Bahama Tan self tanning lotion 1 to 4 (or more) days in a row to achieve YOUR perfect tan color.
  • ORGANIC & NATURAL INGREDIENTS: Bahama Tan Self Tanner is made with pure, natural and organic ingredients perfectly blended to create a rich, natural looking tan without the sun. Eco Cert approved DHA, Food Grade Preservatives and Organic Ingredients like Shea Butter, Coconut Oil, Argan Oil and Monoi de Tahiti Oil that deeply moisturize your skin. Paraben Free and great for all skin types including sensitive skin.
  • NON-TOXIC: Truly a good-for-the-skin sunless tanner with No mineral oils, No lanolin, No parabens, No PABA, No alcohol, No petro-chemicals, No sodium lauryl sulfate, No formaldehyde, No toxic chemicals, No propylene glycol, No butylene glycol, No fillers, and No artificial fragrances.
  • EASY PEASY: Free step-by-step instructions, helpful and little known tips included right on the bottle so you always have everything you need for a beautiful, flawless tan right at your finger tips. One bottle of Bahama Tan Self Tanner is enough for many full body and face applications. Your new sunless tan will last 4 to 7 days.

CHECK: How Soon Can You Tan After a Tattoo?

How to Choose the Best Indoor Tanning Lotion for You

Most of us swear by indoor tanning to get that amazing color and natural glow on our skin.

I mean, what’s not to love about a healthy sunkissed glow? Exactly! But who has the time to hit the beach or soak up the sun? Thank goodness for indoor tanning is all we’re saying.

However, those of us with sensitive skin types can be a sticky spot when choosing quality tanning lotions. Here are a few things to keep in mind when selecting the best tanner for you:

Find a Hypoallergenic Product

Hypoallergenic tanners are made for people who have allergic reactions to certain ingredients, which is a condition that most of us with sensitive skin probably have.

Choosing a hypoallergenic product means we’re choosing natural bronzers over artificial ones such as parabens, THC, and nuts. 

Avoid Tanners That Include ‘tinglers’

Most indoor tanning lotions are infused with tinglers to accelerate the process of tanning. Tinglers contain ingredients such as menthol that increase blood flow.

However, those of us with sensitive skin will do best by steering clear of products with tinglers in the formula. 

Look for Hydrating Tanners

Users with sensitive skin complain of irritation, rashes, and dry skin after their indoor tanning experience.

Such adverse reactions can be avoided by finding a tanner that promotes hydration in the skin. Formulas with shea butter, cocoa butter, or coconut oil work best on sensitive skin.

FAQs

What is the best tanning bed lotion for sensitive skin?

a woman squeezing tanning lotion on her hands

We love several indoor tanning lotions, but our favorite is the Hempz Hypoallergenic Dark Tan Maximizer. It is a 100% vegan formula free of harmful ingredients, making your tanning session worthwhile.

What to put on skin to tan faster?

a blonde lady holding the best tingle tanning lotions

While pondering over the different types of tanning lotions, it is best to look for one with naturally occurring SPF. If you have one without SPF, it is best to apply SPF to accelerate the process of tanning.

Can you indoor tan 2 days in a row?

You can apply dark tan activators onto skin two days in a row, but you may get adverse reactions in doing so. For effective tanning, it is best to skip a day or two between sessions.

What is a good tanning schedule?

Most professionals recommend three tanning sessions per week until you develop a tan. After that, it is best to maintain the deeper color by getting a session done once every two weeks.

Final Thoughts

Indoor tanning may not be the most healthy solution to getting a healthy glow, but if done sparingly, it can help you achieve an “Oh, I just came back from a long beach vacation” look without too much effort.

Let’s get our tan on! 

Our Recommendation

Hempz Dark Tan Maximizer, Hypoallergenic, 9 Ounce
  • 1.Natural calming extracts including Oatmeal to comfort and soothe.
  • 2.Blended with rich Mango Seed Butter to help hydrate and smooth gentle skin.
  • 3.Non-greasy, lighweight formula absorbs quickly into the skin.
  • 4.Paraben Free, Gluten Free, Nut Free, 100% Vegan, THC-Free.
photo of a lady's arms applied with the best indoor tanning lotion for sensitive skin

For you, which is the best indoor tanning lotion for sensitive skin? Please share with us below!

About Edith Russo

Edith is a self-made entrepreneur with a keen business sense that others admire and a total “can-do” attitude. She’s always coming up with new ideas to anticipate her readers’ needs and help solve all their toughest beauty and skincare problems. FOLLOW HER on Linkedin and FACEBOOK